He's Not My President?

Thoreau: "Government is Best Which Governs Least"

Is Bill O’Reilly Really A Stand Up Guy on the Birth Certificate Issue?

bill oreillyOn Monday night Bill O’Reilly began covering the Obama birth certificate controversy in the vane of analyzing Lou Dobbs’ coverage of the issue.  Bill O’Reilly made it clear that he does not agree with those who believe that President Obama was not born in Hawaii.  O’Reilly also pointed out that Lou Dobbs does not agree with the “Birthers.”  Bill O’Reilly defended Lou Dobbs’ right to cover the issue on Lou’s television program.  As a result, Lou Dobbs stated that he does  “appreciate Bill O’Reilly being a stand up guy” found in this video at the 1:42 mark.  But is Bill O’Reilly really a stand up guy on the birth certificate issue?

In the same program where Bill O’Reilly defended Lou Dobbs, he disengenuously used the issue to tout his own program and investigation regarding the birth certificate issue.  During the “Impact Segment” on his program that night he made the following comments which are all distortions of the issue which further fuel the “Birthers” and their birth certificate issue movement:

The Factor investigated it [the birth certificate issue], found out it’s bogus.  (:15 seconds into the video)

Alright again, we found that uh President Obama was born in Hawaii.  We uh were sent the documents and what are you going to do?  I don’t know why it’s still around?  That was more than a year ago.  (:40)

So if he’s [Lou Dobbs is] going to go out there and push a story that is patently absurd.  It is.  It’s an absurd story.  (1:58)

What exactly did the factor do to investigate the birth certificate?  Later in the same program Bill O’Reilly stated something to the effect that the factor had contacted Hawaii and Hawaii had sent The Factor the birth certificate.  I can’t link to the video of this statement because it was in the “Reality Check” segment of the program and has not yet been posted online for review.  I have contacted Fox News to attempt to get a transcript of this portion of the program so that I can cite the words he used verbatim, but again they were something along the lines of Hawaii sent us a copy of the birth certificate.  Talk about absurd.  Mr. O’Reilly is flat out lying to his audience.  If The Factor had contacted Hawaii for a copy of Barack Obama’s birth certificate, they would have received the exact same answer from Hawaii that everyone else has received when attempting to get a copy of the birth certificate that under Hawaii privacy laws, the State of Hawaii is not at liberty to release it.

So why does Bill O’Reilly portray himself and his program as some investigative authority on the birth certificate issue?  Bill O’Reilly claims to be in the business of “looking out for the folks.”  Yet, on Monday night, Bill O’Reilly obfuscated the birth certificate issue, spun a narrative on this issue of investigative journalism in “the no spin zone” and at the end of his program outright lied to his audience.  It is this type of media coverage that Bill O’Reilly participated in on his Monday night program that continues to add fuel to the controversy of the birth certificate issue.  So much for Bill O’Reilly being a stand up guy.

4 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. The time lines, places, actions, motives, when analyzed, support, and are consistent with, what is the answer to the Obama birth puzzle:

    Obama’s grandmother is his mother and his mother is his sister.

    Think about it. Review all the facts and claims.


    July 30, 2009 at 6:46 pm

  2. News flash.. there is no birth certificate “issue”.

    Get over it.

    Try factcheck.org

    It saddens me to think that there are Americans who have become so bitter and negative over nothing. As a country, we have a lot of REAL challenges that we could be working together to find real solutions.

    Why do you waste your time with this nonsense and hate?


    August 1, 2009 at 9:22 am

    • I was not making an argument regarding the validity of those who believe Mr. Obama was not born in Hawaii. In fact, I believe that he was born in Hawaii. The point of my post was that trusted news media should be just that trusted news media. Mr. O’Reilly blatantly lied to his audience that night. You are correct, we have very important issues before us in this country, and that is why it is critcal that we be able to trust the sources in news media for the information we receive. Hence, when Mr. O’Reilly lies to us, I feel a duty to point that out.

      Your comment regarding me somehow being a hater is really disturbing. Since when in this country of looking critically at an issue and holding the media accountable for expressing truth over fiction in support of their own egos and ratings, hate on my part? I want no part of a country where that is the case.


      August 1, 2009 at 2:57 pm

  3. I never thought birth of Obama will become such a big discussion topic. I am following this closely to see where this conspiracy ends. Meanwhile I have collected some good articles and sites related to Barack Obama (more than 200 sites or articles). If you are interested take a look at the below link http://bit.ly/TbblS


    August 3, 2009 at 5:46 pm

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: